Microsoft 365 sits at the center of daily operations for many businesses. Email, file storage, Teams chats, calendars, and often the company directory all live in one tenant. That makes Microsoft 365 security settings some of the most important configuration choices a business can make, and also some of the easiest to overlook.
Microsoft provides a strong set of security features, but many of them depend on how your tenant is configured. Tenants that were set up years ago, or set up quickly to get people working, often carry settings that no longer fit. A focused review of the areas below can significantly reduce the most common risks, such as account takeover and unnoticed data leaks.
Multi-Factor Authentication and Conditional Access
Stolen passwords are one of the most common ways attackers get into Microsoft 365 accounts. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds a second check that a password alone cannot satisfy. Every user should be enrolled, with no exceptions for executives or shared accounts that people sign in to directly.
Depending on your licensing, you can go further with conditional access policies in Microsoft Entra ID. These policies decide whether to allow a sign-in based on conditions such as:
- Whether the user is signing in from an expected country or region
- Whether the device is managed and compliant with company policy
- The sign-in risk level Microsoft detects for the attempt
- Which application is being accessed and how sensitive it is
Smaller tenants without advanced licensing can turn on Microsoft’s security defaults, which enforce baseline MFA protections. Whichever path you choose, favor stronger methods like the Microsoft Authenticator app with number matching, and keep an eye out for repeated, unexpected MFA prompts, which can signal that someone has a user’s password.
Block Legacy Authentication
Older email protocols and clients use what Microsoft calls legacy or basic authentication. These methods cannot enforce MFA, which makes them a favorite target for password-guessing attacks. Microsoft has retired basic authentication for most Exchange Online protocols, but it is still worth confirming that legacy sign-ins are blocked in your tenant and that no older devices, scanners, or line-of-business applications rely on them.
If a multifunction printer or application still needs to send mail, look for a modern alternative, such as an authenticated connector or an app registration, rather than leaving an exception in place.
Limit and Protect Admin Roles
Global administrator accounts can change any setting, read any mailbox through delegation, and create new accounts. Too many of them increases risk. A healthy setup usually includes:
- Few global admins: enough for coverage, but kept to a small number.
- Role-based access: narrower roles like Exchange, SharePoint, or User administrator for people who only need part of the picture.
- Separate admin accounts: admins use a dedicated account for administrative work and a regular account for email and browsing.
- Strong MFA on every admin: preferably phishing-resistant methods.
- An emergency access account: a carefully secured break-glass account in case normal admin access is lost.
Review admin role assignments regularly, and remove access as soon as someone changes jobs or leaves.
External Sharing in SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams
Sharing files with clients and partners is part of normal business, but default settings can allow more than you intend. Check whether anonymous links that work for anyone are allowed, and consider restricting sharing to authenticated guests. Set expiration dates on guest access and sharing links where possible, and limit external sharing on sites that hold sensitive data such as HR or finance records.
In Teams, decide who can add guests and whether external users from other organizations can start chats with your staff. Periodic access reviews help clean up guests who no longer need access.
Mailbox Forwarding Rules
After compromising a mailbox, attackers often create rules that quietly forward copies of incoming mail to an outside address, or move certain messages out of sight so the real user does not notice. This can support invoice fraud and other business email compromise schemes.
Review outbound spam and forwarding policies to block automatic forwarding to external domains unless there is an approved business need. Audit existing inbox rules for anything that forwards, deletes, or redirects messages unexpectedly, and set up alerts for new suspicious rules.
Audit Logging and Backup
When something goes wrong, logs are what allow you to understand what happened. Confirm that unified audit logging is enabled, know how long your license retains audit data, and make sure someone actually reviews alerts. Sign-in logs, admin activity, and mailbox access events are especially useful during an investigation.
Finally, remember that Microsoft 365 retention and recycle bin features are not a full backup. An independent backup of Exchange, OneDrive, SharePoint, and Teams data protects you against accidental deletion, malicious changes, and accounts that are removed before their data is saved.
How Cyber Security Group Can Help
Cyber Security Group reviews and hardens Microsoft 365 tenants, from conditional access and admin roles to sharing policies, alerting, and backup. Learn more about our Microsoft 365 security services, or book a free consultation to have your tenant settings reviewed.
