Phishing and Business Email Compromise: How Small Businesses Became the Quiet Target
A typical Monday morning. I get to the office early to get a jump on a busy week. A number of big clients were expecting proposals and contracts, which had been promised, “absolutely on time.”
At 5:30 AM, I turn on the lights, start the coffee and open my inbox. Near the top is a message from our largest client.
Subject: Updated payment details – urgent. Hi, our bank has changed and the deposit for the new project needs to go to the account below before noon today. Please also review the attached revised contract. You will need to sign in with your email password to open it. Sorry for the rush, our auditors are waiting on this. Thanks so much.
Phishing is perhaps the most common cyber threat facing businesses of all sizes, and small businesses are often far more exposed to it than large and mid-sized enterprises. A phishing email costs attackers almost nothing to send, and it only has to work once.
Phishing is a social engineering attack in which criminals send emails, texts or messages that impersonate someone you trust, such as a bank, a software provider, a vendor, a client or a coworker. The goal is to trick the recipient into clicking a malicious link, opening an infected attachment, entering a password on a fake login page, or sending money. Business email compromise (BEC) is a targeted form of phishing in which attackers pose as an executive, client or supplier to redirect payments or request sensitive data.
The financial impact on a business can be severe. A single convincing email can lead to a fraudulent wire transfer, stolen customer data, or a hijacked mailbox that attackers quietly use to target your clients and vendors. For small businesses, the damage goes beyond money. There is real reputation risk, the cost of cleaning up compromised accounts, and in the worst cases, the possibility of going out of business.
Large organizations are hardly immune. A Malwarebytes’ survey, conducted by Osterman Research, found that nearly 80 percent of large organizations had been the victim of a cyber-attack during the past 12 months (as of August 2016). Small businesses, defined here as companies with 49 or fewer employees, face the very same attackers with a fraction of the resources.
Cyber Security Group, which provides managed IT and cyber security services to growing businesses, surveyed hundreds of US companies and found that small businesses are often missing the people and processes needed to spot an attack like this one before it does damage.
“I almost approved the transfer. Something about the sender’s address looked slightly off, so I called our operations manager, who also acts as our IT guy. He had never heard of business email compromise and had no idea what I was talking about. He certainly didn’t know what to do. Then I learned that two of my coworkers had already opened the ‘revised contract’ and typed in their passwords. I grabbed a pen and paper and started listing every client and vendor those mailboxes had ever emailed, wondering who would receive the next fake invoice.”
The Cyber Security Group survey found that one key difference between large and mid-sized companies and small businesses is that only 17% of small businesses have a dedicated, full-time IT person, much less an IT team. These small businesses typically rely on a go-to person who is partially dedicated to managing the company’s IT assets such as networks, security, email, data backup and phone systems. This lack of IT personnel alone creates incremental risk for small businesses, as their skills and knowledge around spotting phishing and securing email accounts are often limited at best.
Why are phishing emails so effective against small teams? Attackers research their targets on company websites and social media, register look-alike domains, and time their messages for busy moments such as month-end or the start of the week. A request that seems routine, from a name you recognize, rarely gets a second look, and without email filtering, multi-factor authentication and trained employees, a single click can expose the entire business.
Email Security for Small BusinessesCommon warning signs include unexpected requests to change payment or banking details, pressure to act quickly or keep a request confidential, sender addresses that are close to but not exactly right, links that lead to unfamiliar login pages, and attachments you were not expecting. With nearly 28.2 million small businesses in the US (US Small Business Administration, 2011), criminals have no shortage of targets, and they only need one employee to take the bait.
Protecting Your Team from PhishingThe risk to small businesses has been coming into focus for years. In June of 2016, the Infosec Institute noted that “small businesses usually lack sophisticated computer defenses thus making them very vulnerable. An overwhelming majority, some reports by Intel says as much as 80%, of these small and medium scale businesses, don’t employ data protection or email security.”
The good news is that phishing is one of the most preventable threats a business faces. Cyber Security Group recommends a layered approach: advanced email filtering to stop malicious messages before they reach inboxes, multi-factor authentication on every email and cloud account, regular security awareness training with simulated phishing tests, a call-to-verify rule for any payment or banking change, and around-the-clock monitoring to catch compromised accounts quickly.
As it turns out, one quick phone call to the client confirmed the email was a fake. The operations manager reset the exposed passwords, and the business brought in a managed security partner to put email filtering, multi-factor authentication and staff training in place. Looking back, “I’m glad I picked up the phone. We all sleep a lot better now, knowing we’re protected by 24-hour professional watchdogs.”
About Cyber Security Group
Cyber Security Group provides all-in-one managed IT services for growing businesses at small business prices on a secure private cloud platform. The company also provides a full range of cyber security solutions, including email security and protection against phishing. Zohar Pinhasi, CEO of Cyber Security Group, is a cyber security expert and ethical hacker who is often in the media providing expert insights into phishing and other cyber-attacks.
About the Survey
Cyber Security Group surveyed 284 companies in the US in October 2016. The survey classified large business as 250 plus employees, mid-sized business as 50 to 249 employees, and small business as 49 or less employees, consistent with many published definitions. The vast majority of large and mid-sized business respondents were IT vice presidents, IT directors or IT managers. The vast majority of small business respondents were owners, presidents, vice presidents, IT personnel or office managers. A total of 14 questions were included in the survey.
The sales manager and operations manager in this article are an illustrative scenario based on common phishing and business email compromise tactics.
